by Corwin1980
John85 wrote:
I have trouble considering Imrahil from Gondor, but see that it simplifies dynamics; also Dol Amroth is technically in Gondor so I suppose he is of Gondor).
You shouldn't have trouble with that, Dol Amroth is totally Gondor. You seem to consider only Minas Tirith is Gondor, but it's just the frontier where it meets Rohan, and in fact most of Gondor lies further south of the White Mountains, including Dol Amroth and Pelargir.